I have been reading this forum for a few months and figured it was time to actually ask the question that has been keeping me up at night.
I own a leasehold flat I live in (residential mortgage, comfortable payments, no issues there) and a buy-to-let in another city that I bought in 2019. The BTL fixed rate expires in February 2027, so I have roughly six months to decide what I am doing with it.
The numbers as they stand: the BTL is worth approximately £165k based on recent comparable sales. Outstanding mortgage is around £112k. Current rent is £725 pcm. The fixed rate I am on is 2.89% and the best BTL rates I can see right now are in the 5.5% to 6% range for a 75% LTV product. That would push my monthly payment from roughly £370 to somewhere around £530, which would eat most of the margin after costs.
Pros of selling:
- I free up roughly £50k in equity (after fees and CGT)
- No more landlord admin, which I do not enjoy
- I avoid locking in at a much higher rate for another 2 or 5 years
- The market feels flat to falling, so waiting could mean less equity
Pros of remortgaging:
- The flat is in a decent rental area with low void periods
- Property is a long term asset and selling feels like giving up
- Rent could be increased modestly to offset some of the rate increase
- CGT bill on selling is not trivial
I appreciate that nobody can tell me what rates will do (and the base rate being held at 3.75% with talk of further rises does not exactly fill me with optimism), but I would be interested to hear from anyone who has been at a similar crossroads. Did you sell and regret it? Did you remortgage and wish you had not?
Happy to answer any follow up questions. I might even answer some of them.
The numbers answer this for you. £725 rent minus £530 mortgage minus insurance, maintenance, void months, management time. You’re making what, £50 a month before tax? On a property worth £165k with rates heading the wrong way. Sell it, take the equity, put it somewhere it actually works. Holding a btl out of sentiment when the yield is that thin is how people end up subsidising their tenant’s housing.
Dex isn’t wrong on the monthly numbers but I’d push back on the conclusion a bit.. I’ve held properties through three rate cycles now and the ones I regret are the ones I sold, not the ones I kept. The yield looks thin today but rates don’t stay here forever (despite what it feels like right now). And selling in a flat market, with Rightmove asking prices down 2% in a month, means you’re crystallising at the worst possible time.
The other thing nobody mentions is the transaction cost of selling. Agent fees, legal, CGT, potentially an ERC if you’re inside the fix.. You could easily lose £12-15k of that £50k “equity” before you see a penny of it. That’s real money.
That said, if the landlording is genuinely making you miserable and you have no appetite for it, the financial case becomes secondary. Had a flat in Sunderland I kept for eight years longer than I should have purely because the spreadsheet said hold. The spreadsheet was right but I was climbing the walls.. Sometimes the right answer isn’t the one with the best IRR!!
Cheers!
Thanks both, this is exactly the kind of push and pull I was hoping for.
@Dex_777, your point about the monthly cashflow is the thing that keeps me up at night. You are right that on paper the margins are razor thin, and that is before I factor in a void month, which I had last year and cost me the best part of £900 all in.
@theartfulfreeholder, I take your point about regret and the long view. I have been telling myself the same thing. But here is where it gets specific: I have had two remortgage quotes back this week. Best two year fix at 75% LTV is 5.39%, which on the remaining balance of around £112k would put the monthly payment at roughly £690. Rent is currently £825 and the tenant has been there three years, no issues. So I am looking at maybe £135 a month before tax, insurance, and the annual boiler service. After tax (higher rate on the rental income minus the 20% basic rate tax credit on interest) I am probably breaking even or slightly negative on a monthly basis.
The question I keep coming back to is whether breaking even month to month is acceptable if the property is appreciating modestly and the tenant is effectively paying down the capital. I appreciate that is a different question from whether it makes financial sense right now.
El Gato, the “tenant is paying down the capital” line sounds good but think about what it actually means in practice. Your capital is locked in an illiquid asset you can’t access without selling. Meanwhile you are breaking even or losing money every month, taking on all the risk of voids, maintenance, potential regulatory changes, and you are a higher rate taxpayer which makes the rental income almost pointless after Section 24.
What would that £112k do in a global tracker inside an ISA wrapper? Even at modest returns you would be ahead within a few years, with zero tenant risk and zero 3am boiler calls. The appreciation argument only works if you believe your specific property is going to outperform other asset classes over the next decade. Given where rates are sitting and the direction of landlord regulation, that is a bold bet.
@CyclingChap47, fair point and it is one I keep coming back to. The illiquidity is a real issue. If I needed £30k in a hurry for something, I could not get it out of that flat without selling, which takes months and costs thousands in fees.
That said, I am 34 and my thinking is that I do not need liquidity from this asset for at least another decade. The flat is in a strong rental area (university city, consistent demand) and the mortgage balance is relatively low at £87k on a property worth around £155k. Even at 5.6% on a two year fix the rental income covers the mortgage and most of the running costs, though I accept the margin is thin.
What keeps me leaning towards holding is that I have no other investments of any substance. If I sell, I net maybe £55k after fees and CGT, and then what? It sits in a savings account earning less than inflation. At least with the flat I have an asset that (hopefully) appreciates and generates some income, however modest.
But I genuinely have not decided. The rate environment makes it harder to justify than it did two years ago.
El Gato, why would it sit in a savings account? £55k into a global index tracker in an ISA. No CGT on gains. No tenants. No maintenance. No void months. No 3am boiler calls. Historically 7 to 8% annualised returns over any 20 year period.
The fact that you have no other investments is an argument FOR selling the flat, not against. You are 34 with your entire net worth concentrated in two properties in the same asset class. One bad local market correction or one structural survey nightmare and you are exposed.
The rental yield on £155k at current rates is what, 4% gross before costs? You can get 4.5% in a cash ISA right now with zero risk.
Chap is right. Also worth remembering rental income is taxed at your marginal rate and you can’t offset mortgage interest against it any more, only the 20% tax credit. If you’re a higher rate taxpayer that flat is costing you more than you think. £55k in an isa compounds tax free. The maths is pretty clear once you strip the emotion out.
@Dex_777, that is the bit that keeps catching me out. I knew the Section 24 changes were bad but I had not sat down and properly worked through what the 20% tax credit actually means for my specific situation. I am a higher rate taxpayer so the gap between what I pay in tax and what I can offset is significant.
I have booked a meeting with an accountant for next week to run through the full picture, including the CGT implications of selling. Part of me suspects that once I see the numbers laid out properly the decision will make itself. The emotional attachment to the property is real but I am not going to let it cost me money I do not have to lose.
Will report back once I have the meeting. Thanks to everyone who has weighed in on this, it has been genuinely useful.
Good. Make sure you ask them to model the total return over 5 years for both scenarios, not just the annual cashflow. That’s where the real answer is.
@Dex_777, I spoke to the broker yesterday and asked him to do exactly that, the five year total return comparison. Waiting on the numbers but he did say on the phone that with rates where they are now (he quoted me 5.2% for a two year BTL fix, which is higher than I expected) the cashflow is going to look even worse than I thought.
I think I am leaning towards selling, if I am honest. The thread has been really useful for getting my head straight on this. The one complication is the tenancy. My tenant has been there three years and is on a rolling periodic now, so I would need to give two months notice under Section 21 (assuming that is still valid, I keep reading conflicting things about whether it has been abolished yet or not). I would rather not sell with a sitting tenant because it limits the buyer pool significantly.
Has anyone here sold a BTL with a tenant in situ versus vacant? Curious whether the price difference is as big as people say.
El Gato, sold two with tenants in situ and one vacant over the years.. The price difference depends entirely on the buyer. If you sell to another landlord they will want a discount of 10 to 15% versus vacant possession in my experience, because they are pricing in the risk of the tenant and the fact they can’t do any work to the property immediately. If you sell on the open market to an owner occupier you need the property vacant, full stop.
On Section 21.. be very careful here. The Renters Reform Bill received royal assent earlier this year and Section 21 is being phased out, the commencement date for existing tenancies has not been confirmed yet but it could happen before you complete a sale. If you serve a Section 21 now and it is still valid, you have a window. If you wait, you may find yourself needing one of the new grounds instead, which are harder to use for a sale.
Would strongly suggest you take legal advice on the notice before serving anything.. Cheers!
Quick update for anyone still following this. The broker came back yesterday with the five year total return comparison that @Dex_777 suggested I ask for.
The numbers are not pretty. On a remortgage at current rates (best he could find was 5.1% on a two year BTL fix), the total return over five years after mortgage costs, tax, maintenance allowance and one void month per year comes out at roughly £8,200. That is total, not annual. Against that, the capital in the property is about £55k of equity which, as @CyclingChap47 pointed out, could go into an ISA and realistically return somewhere in the region of £18-25k over the same period with no effort, no risk of a 3am boiler call, and no Section 24 headache.
@theartfulfreeholder, I take your point about regret and long term holds, and I genuinely respect that perspective. But I think the environment you built your portfolio in was fundamentally different. The tax treatment alone changes the arithmetic completely.
I am now leaning quite heavily towards selling. The remaining question is whether to sell with the tenant in situ or vacant possession. Artful, your point about the buyer profile is useful. I will think on it over the bank holiday weekend.
£8,200 over five years. That is £1,640 a year before anything goes wrong. One boiler replacement wipes out two years of return. The numbers have answered the question for you. On the tenant in situ point, sell vacant. You will get a better price from owner occupiers than from landlord buyers hunting a discount. The hassle of ending the tenancy is worth it for the uplift.
El Gato, fair enough.. Those numbers are hard to argue with, and I won’t pretend the tax environment hasn’t changed fundamentally since I started out. Section 24 has killed the maths for leveraged single property landlords, no question about it.
One last thought before you pull the trigger though. If you don’t need the £55k urgently, there is an argument for waiting six to twelve months before listing. The market is soft right now, Savills are forecasting a 2% drop this year, and Rightmove asking prices just had their biggest August fall since 2018. Selling into that is selling at or near a local low. If rates come down (and Oxford Economics seem to think 3.75% might hold well into 2027 but they’ll come down eventually), buyer demand picks up and you get a better price.
That said, if the mental load of being a landlord is weighing on you then sometimes the right price is whatever gets you out. I’ve been there too!!
Best wishes whatever you decide..
Right, decision made. I am going to sell.
I have been going back and forth on this for weeks now but the five year numbers the broker produced, combined with the points Chap and Dex have been making about opportunity cost, have tipped it. The total return after tax, maintenance provision, and void risk comes out at roughly £1,600 a year. I could get better than that in a cash ISA with zero hassle. The tenant is on a periodic tenancy so I will need to give two months notice under Section 21 (assuming that is still valid, I know there have been rumblings about abolition but nothing concrete yet for existing tenancies as far as I can tell).
The plan is to instruct an agent in the next couple of weeks, probably market it in early October once the tenant has vacated, and aim to complete before Christmas. Whether the market cooperates with that timeline is another matter, given what Dave’s Rightmove thread suggests about how long things are sitting.
Genuinely appreciate everyone’s input on this thread. It has been exactly the kind of structured, honest pushback I was looking for. I might even stick around and help someone else with their dilemma (famous last words).
El Gato, fair play for making the call.. It takes a certain discipline to look at the numbers and not let sentiment or “what if” thinking overrule them.
I will say this though, and I am not trying to change your mind because the maths is the maths. I sold a two bed terrace in Gateshead in 2014 for £78k. Thought I was being clever, rates were low, yields were thin, didn’t want the hassle any more. That property sold again last year for £142k. The tenant who was in it when I sold had been there since 2009 and was still there when the new owner sold it on!! I think about that one more than I should..
But that was a different tax regime, a different rate environment, and frankly a different market. Section 24 changed everything for higher rate payers and if your numbers say £1,600 a year before anything goes wrong then you are right to walk away.
Good luck with the sale.. Keep us posted on how the agent valuations come in. Cheers!